What does a recruiting platform's data export actually preserve?

Natural workspace photo for What does a recruiting platform's data export actually preserve
On this page
  1. Question and scope
  2. What an export is for
  3. Build a field inventory
  4. Check the film and attachments
  5. Test the format and portability
  6. Test a re-import before you need it
  7. Understand deletion and retention
  8. Security of the export file
  9. Limits and next step
  10. Sources

Key Stats

1 export fileUnit of reviewSource: Fixed review protocol
Profile, film, messagesRecords comparedSource: Test design
3 linked referencesOfficial sourcesSource: NIST and FTC

Key Takeaways

  • An export is only useful if it preserves the athlete's profile, the film references, and the message context, not just a list of names.
  • Open the export on a machine that is not signed in to the platform and check whether every link still resolves.
  • Test a re-import into a second account before trusting the export as a backup.
  • Record the export date and the platform version so a later reviewer knows what changed.
  • Ask what the platform deletes or retains after cancellation, and get the answer in writing.

Question and scope

This review asks what a recruiting platform's data export actually preserves when a family downloads its account. The unit is one export produced by one platform at one point in time. The review does not compare the quality of recruiting data or the size of a coach network. It compares the exported record with the live account and asks whether a family could reconstruct the important parts without the platform.

The scope includes the athlete profile, the film and video references, the message history, and the documents a family uploaded. It excludes billing records unless the platform includes them in the same export. A CSV of profile fields is not enough if the film links point to a private player or the messages lose their timestamps. The review treats the export as a record, not as a marketing feature.

The family is the unit of decision because one parent may open the account, another may keep the receipts, and the athlete may be the person whose film and messages are at stake. An export that only the purchaser can read is a weak handoff. The review therefore checks whether a second person can understand the file without access to the original account. That test should include the film links and the message threads, not just the profile fields.

What an export is for

An export can serve three different purposes: backup, migration, and evidence. A backup lets the family restore the account after a mistake or a cancellation. A migration lets the athlete move to a new platform without losing the profile and film links. Evidence lets the family show what a coach or service said at a particular time. One file rarely serves all three purposes well, so the family should decide which purpose matters most before testing.

A platform may offer a "download your data" button that produces a machine-readable archive, a PDF summary, or a set of links. Those formats are not interchangeable. A PDF is readable but hard to re-import, while a JSON archive may be complete but unusable without a viewer. The family should record the format and open it with the tools it actually has.

The export should also state what it excludes. Some platforms omit messages with coaches, internal notes, or files above a size limit. Those omissions are not always visible in the download. The family should compare the export against the live account and write down the missing categories rather than assuming the file is complete.

Build a field inventory

List the fields the family needs before opening the export. A useful list includes the athlete's name, graduation year, position, height and weight, GPA, test scores, contact details, school, club team, and eligibility status. Add the profile photo, the film links, the coach contact list, and the message threads. The list should reflect the recruiting decisions the family makes, not every field the platform happens to store.

For each field, record whether the export contains it, whether the value matches the live account, and whether the format is usable. A field that appears as a blank column is not preserved in any meaningful sense. A field that appears only as an image is harder to reuse than a text value. The inventory should be specific enough that a second person can repeat the check.

Pay attention to fields that change over time, such as graduation year, GPA, and film links. An export that captures only the current value cannot show how the profile looked when a coach first saw it. If the family needs that history, it should ask whether the platform keeps a change log. The absence of a change log is a limit, not necessarily a defect.

Check the film and attachments

Film is often the most important asset in a recruiting account and the easiest thing to lose. Export the links and open each one on a device that is not signed in to the platform. If a link requires a login, expires, or points to a page that no longer exists, the export has not preserved the film. A link that works only for the account owner is not a portable record.

Download the actual video files if the platform permits it and if the family has the rights to keep them. Store the files with a checksum or a clear file name so a later copy can be compared. If the platform does not allow downloads, record that limitation and keep the original source file elsewhere. The export should not be the only copy of a highlight reel.

Attachments such as transcripts, offer letters, and camp confirmations need the same check. Open each file and confirm that it is the version the family expects. A zip archive that contains a zero-byte file is a failure even if the file name looks right. Note the size and the date of each attachment in the inventory.

Test the format and portability

Open the export on a computer that is not signed in to the platform and does not have the platform's app installed. That test shows whether the file is self-contained or depends on the service. If the export is a CSV, check whether the column headers are meaningful without a separate data dictionary. If it is a JSON file, check whether the structure is documented.

Try importing the export into a second account or a spreadsheet. A successful import does not have to be perfect, but it should preserve the key fields and the film links. Record what breaks and whether the break is caused by the format or by missing data. The family should know before cancelling whether the export can be used elsewhere.

Keep the original export file unchanged and work from a copy. A family that edits the only export can destroy the evidence it needs later. Store the original with a date and a note about the platform version. The copy is for testing, and the original is for the record.

Test a re-import before you need it

A re-import test is the closest a family can get to a real migration without committing to one. Create a free account on a second platform or use a blank spreadsheet and import the key fields. Check whether the athlete's name, graduation year, position, and film links survive. If the receiving system rejects a field, note the error and the workaround.

Do not judge the re-import by whether the layout looks the same. Judge it by whether the information needed for a coach to evaluate the athlete is present and correct. A profile that loses the film link but keeps the favorite color is not a successful migration. The re-import test should be scored against the field inventory, not against a general impression.

If a full re-import is not possible, test a partial import with one film link and one message thread. Even a partial test can reveal hidden dependencies such as a required account ID or a proprietary link format. Record the result and keep the test files with the export. The family should repeat the test after a major platform update.

Understand deletion and retention

An export is not a deletion guarantee. The platform may keep a copy after the family cancels, or it may delete the account on a schedule the family does not control. Ask what happens to the data after cancellation and how long the platform retains it. Get the answer in writing if the family is relying on deletion for privacy.

The NIST Privacy Framework is a useful structure for asking about data handling, though it is voluntary guidance rather than a legal rule. The FTC data security guidance explains why a company should protect the personal information it holds. Neither source tells the family what a specific platform does; the platform's own policy and support reply do. Ask the platform to quote the retention period in the reply so the family can keep it with the export.

If the family needs a complete deletion, follow the platform's stated process and keep the confirmation. Check whether the process covers backups and third-party processors. A deletion confirmation that only covers the visible profile may leave the message history and billing records in place. Record the gap and decide whether it matters for the family's situation.

Security of the export file

An export often contains more personal information than the live profile because it includes messages and documents. Store it in an encrypted folder or a password-protected archive. Do not email it to a coach or a helper without a secure link. If the family shares the file, use view-only access and remove it when the review is done.

Check who else has access to the account before exporting. A former helper with an active session could download the same data. Change the password and revoke sessions before producing a sensitive export. The CISA Secure Our World guidance covers account hygiene, and the FTC identity theft guidance explains what to do if the file is exposed.

Keep the export out of public cloud folders that are indexed or shared by link. A recruiting file may include a home address, a birth date, or a transcript. Those details are not appropriate for a public link even if the file name looks harmless. The family should treat the export like a financial record, not like a highlight video.

Limits and next step

This review cannot tell a family whether a platform is worth keeping. It can show whether the export is complete enough to support a backup, a migration, or an evidence request. The result may change after a platform update, a plan change, or a support ticket. The family should record the date and the account type with the export.

A reasonable next step is to run the field inventory once per season and repeat the re-import test before renewing an annual plan. If the export fails, ask the platform for a complete archive before the renewal date. The family guide to comparing renewal terms covers the cancellation window, while this review covers what the family keeps after it leaves. Both checks should be repeated whenever the platform changes its plan page.

Sources

Related Research

Recruiting Operations Evidence

How reliable are coach attendance counts at recruiting showcases?

A way to read showcase coach-attendance claims by checking definitions, denominators, verification methods, and the difference between a listed coach and a coach who evaluates.

Recruiting Operations Evidence

How should a family compare coaching-change clauses in recruiting agreements?

A structured way to compare what happens to an offer, a visit, or a signed agreement when a coach leaves, before the family relies on a verbal assurance.

Recruiting Operations Evidence

How should a family test a recruiting service's response-time claim?

A bounded method for checking a recruiting service's response-time promise with a small, documented test instead of relying on a sales page or a single anecdote.